Catholic League: “Not all gay sex is abusive”

By Ruth Schneider, 365gay.com
26th Apr 2010

The president of the Catholic League released a statement today condemning a New York Times story describing years of abuse suffered by a handful of a Chilean priest’s parishioners.

news-catholic-priest-topIn a statement called “Not All Gay Sex is Abusive,” Catholic League President Bill Donohue called the treatment of followers of Father Karadima not abusive, but rather a “homosexual relationship.”

Karadima is accused of sexually abusing select followers for decades. In one case, James Hamilton, now 44, said he was abused for more than 20 years by Karadima – from the time he was 17, until he was in his late-30s.

“If a 17-year old guy has sex with an older guy for twenty years, and continues to have sex with him at the age of 38 — while he is married with children — is there anyone who would believe his claim that he was sexually abused?” Donohue said.

He continues: “Why would the New York Times try to sell this so-called abuse story with a straight face? For two reasons: It wallows in stories designed to weaken the moral authority of the Catholic Church, and it is so gay-friendly as to be gay-crazy.”

While Donohue calls the priest a disgrace for maintaining covert homosexual relationships, he blames the victims for allowing it to happen.

“Let me be very clear about this: If some guy tried to kiss me when I was 17, I would have flattened him. I most certainly would not go on a retreat with the so-called abuser, unless, of course, I liked it,” he said.